Rereading old journals: what to do when you meet your past self.
You find an old notebook at the back of the closet, open it to a random page, and there you are, eight years ago, worried about something you cannot even remember now. Some pages make you wince. This note shows you how to approach rereading old journals without the sting: how to read, what to look for, the questions to answer and what to do with the notebooks afterward.
Read her like a letter from a younger friend.
The cringe is real, and it is normal. You are reading the private thoughts of someone who did not know how the job would turn out, whether the friendship would last or which worry would dissolve on its own. Of course some of it sounds naive. You are reading it with the answers.
The discomfort is not evidence that you got things wrong. It is evidence that you changed. So before you open the notebook, decide how you will treat her. Read her the way you would read a letter from a younger friend. You would not mock her or roll your eyes at her worries. You would feel a little protective of her.
Three practical choices make this easier:
- Read in daylight, with something warm to drink, rather than late at night when everything feels heavier.
- Read one season at a time, not an entire year in one sitting.
- Keep a fresh page beside you for notes, so the rereading becomes a conversation instead of a verdict.
If a section brings up something that still feels raw, you are allowed to close the notebook and come back another day, or to talk it through with someone you trust. You set the pace.
She was doing her best with what she knew. So are you.
What to look for when rereading old journals.
Rereading is most useful when you go in looking for something specific. Three things are worth watching for.
Patterns.
The same complaint in March and again in October. The same wish written every January. The same kind of week that leaves you depleted, or the same small thing that shows up whenever you sound most like yourself. Patterns are invisible from inside a single day, which is why a journal is so good at showing them.
Wishes that came true.
Many of the things you once hoped for arrived quietly while you were too busy to notice. The home, the friend, the skill, the calmer mornings. Write down three wishes from the old pages that are true now.
Worries that did not.
The move you dreaded. The conversation you rehearsed for weeks. Make a short list of the worries that never came to pass. The next time a worry insists it is certain, you will have evidence on paper that worries are not predictions.
A twenty minute look back you can repeat each season.
You do not have to wait for a box in the closet. Once a month, or once a season if monthly feels like too much, set aside twenty minutes. Reread the last stretch of pages and answer a few of these on a new one.
LOOK BACK QUESTIONS
- What kept coming up, in different words?
- What did you worry about that did not happen?
- What did you want then that you have now?
- When did you sound most like yourself?
- What were you tolerating that you could not see at the time?
- What would you tell the woman who wrote these pages?
- What do you want to carry into the next season?
- What are you ready to leave behind?
A weekly record makes this much easier, because the raw material is already there. The Year of You, an undated weekly planner, closes each week with a five minute Reap, a few honest lines about what actually happened, so by the end of a season you have a short, readable record to look back on. When the year ends, these questions pair well with a longer set of year end reflection questions.
What should you do with old journals?
There is no right answer, only the one that fits you. Some women keep every notebook they have ever filled. Others let them go once they have served their purpose. Both are reasonable.
- If you keep them, give them a proper home: a box labeled by year, stored somewhere dry, where you can find them when you want them.
- If you keep some, save a single page from each notebook, or write a short summary of what that year held, and let the rest go.
- If you let one go, give it a last read first, then shred it. If privacy matters to you, decide now rather than leaving it to chance.
You are allowed to let a notebook go. Its work was done when you wrote it.
Write a note back to your past self.
Before you put the notebook away, notice what has stayed the same: the colors you always described, the places you kept wanting to go, the quiet things that made you happy at twenty eight and still do. Write a few of them on a short list titled "still true." It is proof that you did not lose yourself in the busy years.
Then write a short letter. One paragraph, addressed to the woman who wrote the pages, from where you stand now. Tell her what happened. Tell her which worries she could have put down. Thank her for what she kept going through when nobody noticed.
Tuck the note inside the cover. The next time you open the notebook, she will not be alone on the page. If you want to keep the thread going in a fresh notebook, these journaling prompts for self discovery pick up where the old pages leave off.
Not a verdict. A conversation with the woman you were.
ONE THING FOR THIS WEEK
Choose one old notebook, or the last month of the one you keep now. Read it in daylight with a fresh page beside you. Write down one worry that never came true and one wish that did.
Be kind to the woman on the page.
ABOUT THE WRITER
Cari Hawthorne is the founder of Discover HER Collection and the creator of The Year of You, an undated planner for the woman who is ready to come first in her own life.